This personal statement was submitted as part of a successful application to a top-10 program in English Literature in 2009.
My academic interests have thus far traveled along two separate but parallel tracks: medieval studies and twentieth-century literature, particularly works stemming from the First World War. In my thinking and writing over the last several years, these tracks have steadily converged. I have come to believe that a study of how medieval temporalities haunt the testimony of the First World War can be an oblique but illuminating intervention in medieval studies capable of speaking to questions of alterity and time. These questions have prompted some of the most energetic scholarship and debate in medieval studies in recent years, as the presumption of alterity, long an organizing principle of the field, has come under challenge. Various scholars have called attention to the desires that inform modern attempts to totalize and stabilize a medieval past, highlighted the ideological work such constructions of the period have performed for modernity, and offered alternative visions of a heterogeneous Middle Ages that remains contiguous with and embedded in subsequent periods.
An inquiry from the perspective of the First World War speaks to these currents in medieval studies because a sense of uncanny proximity to medieval temporalities pervades First World War writing. Many authors marked by the war – among them David Jones, J.R.R. Tolkien, T.E. Lawrence, Robert Graves, and Edmund Blunden– demonstrate the kind of apprehension exemplified in Blunden’s thoughts on the ruins of Ypres in his memoir Undertones of War: “The Middle Ages had here contrived to lurk, and this was their torture at last.” This observation, with its eerie ambiguities (is “this” the torture of “the Middle Ages” or by them?), suggests both deep unease and startling revisionary potential. Blunden’s sense of something medieval at an epicenter of modern industrialized conflict testifies to profound disorientation: a disturbing loss of surety of the self and present, along with a disruption of received notions of historical lineage and temporal linearity. In Great War testimony, the medieval often reemerges wherever modernity appears to have shattered its own self-identity and betrayed its own narrative; as Blunden muses in one of his war poems, “This is not what we were formerly told."
Instead of being seen as symptoms of a crisis of progress and identity, such disorienting moments of untimely contiguity can be recast as signs of a fundamental disjuncture in both modern and medieval time – hence their revisionary power. These medieval/modern time-knots can become another means of theorizing not only what Dipesh Chakrabarty calls “the noncontemporaneity of the present with itself” but also the noncontemporaneity with itself of a medieval past freed from the necessity of uniformly mirroring the desired self-contemporaneity of the present. In other words, the experiences of radical temporal disorientation attested to in Great War testimony do not merely exemplify the fracturing of a universalized Western historicism. These experiences of disorientation and fracture take the form of perceptions of affective medieval presences, and such presences highlight the plurality and fluidity of their ostensibly uniform and static medieval contexts. The embedded traces of the medieval through which First World War authors convey their impressions of contemporary disjuncture testify to a heterogeneous Middle Ages from which modernity cannot detach itself. Moreover, the alignment of medieval and modern in these Great War texts provides a basis for new, nonlinear temporal affiliations that can further illuminate medieval self-difference by threading together the author’s present with specific medieval pasts: for example, Blunden with late-medieval Ypres, Jones with post-Roman Britain, Lawrence with Crusader Outremer. In this manner, a study of the medieval ghosts pervading First World War literature can produce new temporal lifelines that open up uniform medieval alterity.
Past and present scholarship by faculty at ... provides suggestive models, resources, and spurs for this project, in its various dimensions. ...’s work on historicist approaches to medieval literature has probed and critiqued such blanket suppositions of medieval uniformity and alterity as the notion (inherited, as ... shows, from the biases of the period’s own governing discourses) of a fixed and absolute correlation between peasantry and illiteracy. In his study of the role of literacy and literary representations during and after the 1381 Peasant’s Revolt, ... argues against interpretations of the revolt, rooted in contemporary chronicle descriptions, as anti-intellectual, anti-literate, or in any way ignorant or naïve, maintaining instead that the revolt evinces a peasant political culture marked by, at least, a desire to claim and insert themselves into the sphere of literacy and its corollary right to govern. While always drawing attention to the difference of the period, ... also exhibits the resistance of a medieval past to stabilization as the uniform other, in which, for example, peasants entirely lacked any literary culture or political consciousness. ...’s judgment that “The story of how the rising was remembered is the story of how it was forgotten, of the cultural and psychic machinery that engaged to keep it in the preterite” intriguingly connects the historiographical fate of the revolt during the Middle Ages with the historiographical fate of “the Middle Ages” themselves, at least for a long time, in the eyes of modernity. This formulation resonates with those moments in Great War literature when the medieval past directly escapes from “the preterite” into the present.
My work at ... has been inspired by an abiding interest in exactly these types of issues – the strategic use of the past to address contemporary concerns, the past’s inherence in a fractured present, literary-historical relationships, and temporality. These interests have led me to the study of alternative temporal theories and to the contrapuntal reading of the ingrained tensions within medieval texts. My interest in temporality found expression in a paper on the non-linear theory of history and time in David Jones’ The Anathemata, juxtaposing it with similar but distinct works by Derrida and Amitav Ghosh. This paper opened avenues both to the First World War, since Jones's unique perspective on temporality owes a great deal to his experience in the spectral and strangely atemporal environment of the trenches, and to a heterogeneous Middle Ages, particularly the subaltern Welsh history and literature with which Jones affiliated himself. I also took a direct approach to medieval texts as spaces of polyvocal contestation in a paper on Beowulf and The Song of Roland, focusing on Hildeburh and Roland’s mother as parallel figures that collapse normative oppositions and thus must be systematically erased by the poems’ internal logic. This approach, by seeking to reclaim such works from the closure and monologism often enforced by a simple understanding of medieval alterity, leads back around to questions of temporality; at the conjunction of the two lies an understanding of the openness and dynamism of medieval texts and the “intimate alterity” they and their period form with the modern world.
Recasting the medieval past in this light will not be any less of a construction, discursively framed and governed in part by modern desires; it will not enable the period to speak in its own voices, free of mediation. But looking past the veil of absolute and self-identical alterity, particularly at a time when “medieval” in its crudest sense still serves as a cutting political instrument, can help put the reality behind that term beyond our utilitarian and self-justifying reach – and thus, paradoxically, bring it closer to us by showing that it was never so distinct in the first place. To revise sheer medieval alterity through the Great War testimonies that interconnect medieval and modern is to attempt to be more faithful and more just to the pasts that were and the futures that might have been.
Friday, November 26, 2010
Sample Statement of Purpose 1
This personal statement was submitted as part of a successful application to a top-10 program in English Literature in 2009. Five sentences have been removed due to their highly personal content.
The study and teaching of Old English poetry lies at the convergence of an improbably large number of my longtime fascinations: second language acquisition, medieval literature, the literature of distress and personal extremity, and the theory and practice of religious ritual. In particular, I am interested in the diverse ways in which overwhelming private emotion can interact with powerful social institutions or prevailing social practices. To examine these questions, I intend to make use of the theory and methodology that I have previously employed as a student of religion and ritual practice. As my writing sample demonstrates, I have recently striven to locate a critical vantage point from which to take stock of both the theoretical and the historical problems posed by early medieval texts. My outlook on these writings has been influenced by my readings in critical theory (for instance, Althusser on ideology and Butler on gender), readings which I conducted at ... and at ... At the same time, largely due to my coursework in ...'s English program, I have increasingly sought to ground my discussion of these theoretical problems in historical sourcework.
As a ... student, I hope to conduct research under the guidance of ..., a critical theorist and Anglo-Saxonist whose work, like mine, has centered on Old English texts and early religious writing. As I progress in the Ph.D. program, I hope to focus on the elegiac tradition in Old English, examining its characteristic expressions of distress and loss. While the notion of "trauma" clearly belongs to modernity, my background in the study of trauma leads me to think that contemporary theory on human responses to loss may have bearing on Old English literature. Specifically, I hope to examine the poems in light of the models of ritual provided by attachment theory, which I have previously encountered in courses taught by ethnographer ... Such an approach takes advantage of the historical contextualization already provided by philologists: many of the conventions of Old English elegy likely have their roots in early Germanic funeral rites. While this approach is in many ways comparative and theoretical, it is also founded in models that have been validated by extensive anthropological fieldwork and previously applied to other folkloric subgenres, such as Irish funeral lament...
From 2003 to the present, I have served as an ESL teacher and curriculum planner at ... Both the teaching of ESL and the study of Old English combine the close reading of literature with a rigorous approach to the study of a foreign language, one reason I enjoy them both. I am convinced that ...'s English department provides an environment in which I can flourish, both as a maturing teacher and as a maturing Anglo-Saxonist, and that the strengths of the program are powerfully matched to my own scholarly interests and goals.
The study and teaching of Old English poetry lies at the convergence of an improbably large number of my longtime fascinations: second language acquisition, medieval literature, the literature of distress and personal extremity, and the theory and practice of religious ritual. In particular, I am interested in the diverse ways in which overwhelming private emotion can interact with powerful social institutions or prevailing social practices. To examine these questions, I intend to make use of the theory and methodology that I have previously employed as a student of religion and ritual practice. As my writing sample demonstrates, I have recently striven to locate a critical vantage point from which to take stock of both the theoretical and the historical problems posed by early medieval texts. My outlook on these writings has been influenced by my readings in critical theory (for instance, Althusser on ideology and Butler on gender), readings which I conducted at ... and at ... At the same time, largely due to my coursework in ...'s English program, I have increasingly sought to ground my discussion of these theoretical problems in historical sourcework.
As a ... student, I hope to conduct research under the guidance of ..., a critical theorist and Anglo-Saxonist whose work, like mine, has centered on Old English texts and early religious writing. As I progress in the Ph.D. program, I hope to focus on the elegiac tradition in Old English, examining its characteristic expressions of distress and loss. While the notion of "trauma" clearly belongs to modernity, my background in the study of trauma leads me to think that contemporary theory on human responses to loss may have bearing on Old English literature. Specifically, I hope to examine the poems in light of the models of ritual provided by attachment theory, which I have previously encountered in courses taught by ethnographer ... Such an approach takes advantage of the historical contextualization already provided by philologists: many of the conventions of Old English elegy likely have their roots in early Germanic funeral rites. While this approach is in many ways comparative and theoretical, it is also founded in models that have been validated by extensive anthropological fieldwork and previously applied to other folkloric subgenres, such as Irish funeral lament...
From 2003 to the present, I have served as an ESL teacher and curriculum planner at ... Both the teaching of ESL and the study of Old English combine the close reading of literature with a rigorous approach to the study of a foreign language, one reason I enjoy them both. I am convinced that ...'s English department provides an environment in which I can flourish, both as a maturing teacher and as a maturing Anglo-Saxonist, and that the strengths of the program are powerfully matched to my own scholarly interests and goals.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)